Cause-related Marketing: Generosity Water
Blog
Post #3: Cause-related Marketing
Maggie A., Gillian D., Lisa S., and Shelby W.
June 29, 2018
June 29, 2018
What
is Cause-related Marketing?
Cause-related marketing can be defined as the “design
of corporate initiatives that enable charities to profit from a revenue-providing
exchange that fits both the consumer and company objectives” (Guerreiro and
Rita, 2015, p. 1729). Usually, with a CRM initiative, a specific donation
amount is tied directly to the sales of a product as the initiative is designed
to promote the former’s sales and the latter’s cause. Essentially, with
cause-related marketing, products are marketed normally through advertising and
point of purchase, but the donation aspect of the promotion is added to the
advertising and packaging of the product.
The
benefits of cause-related marketing?
Cause-related marketing campaigns help increase the
brand awareness in new markets, customer goodwill and help companies gain new
customers who are motivated by their desire for the cause to try a product for
the first time. Researchers have found that “consumers prefer charity
incentives, rather than promotions when buying frivolous versus practical
products” (Guerreiro and Rita, 2015, p. 1729). Charities often benefit from the
increased exposure, which increases donations. Brand building can be beneficial
for both the company and the party if they are a good match and their values
align.
What
are the potential drawbacks of Cause-related Marketing?
Guerreiro and Rita (2015) explain that “the motivation
of a company to support a cause is a key determinant of cause-related marketing
effectiveness” (p. 1729). Consumers often get wear when a company supports a
cause; they immediately think the business has an ulterior motive and the
charity is insignificant in comparison to the benefits to the company. It can
also be quite tasking and costly for the charity and company to set up the
systems required to track sales and donations and develop advertising and
packaging.
Steps
to developing a cause-related campaign
1.
Situation
assessment
2. Objective setting
3. Target audience selection
4. Creating a marketing mix
5. Developing budgets, timelines and
evaluation criteria.
Case
Study: Generosity Water
Generosity was launched in 2015 with the mission to
help people with life’s most basic need. Through their site, they educate
people about the current global water crisis, explaining that “there are
currently 663 million people in the world that do not have access to clean
drinking water and each year this crisis kills more people than war, AIDS, and
famine combined” (Generosity, n.d.). They express their commitment to ending
the water crisis in this lifetime and encourage their customers to join them in
breaking the cycle first by providing access to water to create a lasting
change by improving health, economic growth, access to education and equality
for women and children who are less fortunate.
Generosity’s
CRM initiative and why it’s attractive to customers
Generosity’s slogan: “more than selling water, we
believe that people matter and everything we do is an expression of that
fundamental value” (Generosity, n.d.), is a very inspiring call to action, that
would motivate people to act immediately. According to Guerreiro and Rita
(2015) “the image of the brand regarding its efficiency in helping charities is
of the utmost importance to reduce consumer scepticism and it depends on the
charity’s efficiency in using donors money to positively impact society” (p.
1729).
Generosity has done a great job developing a strong
brand, from their name, to their logo and slogan, they are clear and consistent
in stating what their mission is. They have developed a brand that is memorable
and easily differentiated from their competitors. How? They don’t simply
provide water to those in need, they provide “alkaline water with a Ph balance
of 10.0 to provide optimal hydration and help neutralize your body”
(Generosity, n.d.).Their website, as previously mentioned, educates consumers
on the current water crises and uses ethos, logos and pathos to adequately
explain the severity of the situation.
On a more superficial level, Generosity’s page is very
aesthetically pleasing and simple. The text, colours, white space and even their
bottles present a luxurious product mimicking the likes of Fiji water and Smart
water that are well-know semi luxurious water charity brands. This immediately
prompts consumers to associate this product, Generosity with quality,
instilling their trust in the initiative.
Potential
Pitfalls of Generosity Water
The ‘glamour’ of the website trivializes the global
water crisis. Upon accessing the landing page of this website, they appear to
be a water company and nothing more, The landing page features an image of a
beautiful woman on what appears to be a yacht. Except for the name that implies
that you are ‘giving’ there is not much that prompts a consumer to think about
the cause first. Generosity water makes it a point to differentiate themselves
from their consumers stating that by producing a high-quality alkaline water
they are “generous to [their] health and generous to people” (Generosity,
n.d.).This is a brand is an example of an organization that loses consumer
interest because they appear to be more concerned about their bottom line that
the cause.
At the very bottom of their landing page, it is
mentioned that for every bottle of water purchased, Generosity provides two
people in need with clean water for one month (Generosity, n.d.). Again, this information
is placed at the bottom of the page, which will not convince consumers of the
brand’s dedication to the cause. Under this section, there is an image of a
bottle and a prompt stating that by “scan[ning] the QR code on your bottle
[you] can see the exact community you helped with your purchase” (Generosity,
n.d.), yet the website doesn’t offer that feature.
The “Projects Funded” tab in the navigation menu
redirects you to a page with two options – Learn
How We Give and Buy Cases Online.
While you can click through to buy as many cases as you want and have them
delivered to your home, the Learn How We
Give section redirects you to a FAQs page that only addresses questions
about Generosity water - its advantage
over competitors, where its made and its benefits. This CRM initiative can be a
significant drawback to Generosity for all of the aforementioned reasons.
Essentially, this organization is at risk of being perceived as a business that
is exploiting a charity because the money that is allocated to the cause is
insignificant in comparison to the company’s profits.
References
Guerreiro, J., Rita, P., & Trigueiros, D.
(2015). Attention, emotions and cause-related marketing effectiveness. European
Journal of Marketing, 49(11/12), 1728–1750. doi:10.1108/EJM-09-2014-0543
Generosity
(n.d.) Retrieved June 26, 2018 from http://generositywater.com/
This was a very insightful read regarding cause-related marketing and how it can be great as well as potentially controversial. Looking at Generosity Water’s website I find myself agreeing with both your points regarding the effects of their aesthetics. They have a very well done website and I definitely found myself viewing the organization as legitimate and of high quality as you pointed out. This was a brand that upon first look stands out and seems trustworthy due to the high levels of effort and thought put behind all of the graphics and copy throughout the website. However, your points regarding the trivialization of the global water crisis and putting the aesthetic and luxury at the forefront of the website was eye-opening and completely pivoted my opinion of the brand’s CRM efforts. I believe that having good design is important and can be influential in the direction of the communications, however it should not overshadow the narrative of the brand and its CRM, but rather complement it.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your thoughts and research!
-Ryann
After reading this blog I decided to take a deeper look into the generosity water’s website pitfalls. When taking a look at the website I would have to agree with what you pointed out in your blog post about the major things that they are lacking and not very clear on. I think the photo looks professionally done but has nothing to do with the work they are doing. It should be clearer that they are a charity and what exactly they are giving to. I agree that they seem that they are losing customers because ‘they appear to be more concerned about their top line then the cause’. It seems like they are very concerned about the way they look (brand wise) in comparison to consumers that want to donate to the charity itself. In this day and age, it is obviously important to make your brand image look professional, but there is certain industry where it isn’t necessarily about the “sex appeal” and more about the “what”. Really enjoyed this post!
ReplyDeleteHmm. I made a comment on Sunday night, but maybe I forgot to publish it, or some technical glitch..
ReplyDeleteBut here again is my comment for you all.
Maggie and gang, this was a valuable post for me to read. I liked your source from the Journal of Marketing, it helped solidify the concept of cause-related marketing using different language, and especially valuable were the steps that you found in that article to develop a cause-related marketing campaign. I will be grabbing a copy of that article and referring to again in the future I'm sure.
Especially valuable to me is step 4 of developing a marketing mix, something that get overlooked when if we analyzed these cases with just a PR lens.
Further, using those steps to analyze your case study, I'm mostly curious if you found any research on their financial statements or such, using other resources to help evaluate where their cause related funds actually go in terms of their projects and operating costs. I looked around their website, like you, to discover this kind of information was lacking; in fact, the scroll over the circles function did not even work when I used it, and I refreshed my page multiple times. Basically what I'm seeing as a trend to my own case study is that pertinent information in terms of fundraising and spending of those funds gets packaged in a beautiful website, with attractive clean and modern looking info-graphics, however what is missing for me is the substance of how they truly put the money raised to use.
You raised that with your point on your analysis of the 'learn how we give page:' all fluff, but minimal substance. Furthermore, your analysis about the visual branding of the beautiful all-American woman versus the contrast of actual global human benefit provided in developing nations was bang on!
Now, if this was your baby as a Mar-Comms expert, what would you tweak to portray a different message, a different feel? What would need to change for you to do so? Do you think you'd have any ethical considerations or dilemmas in your task?
Cheers
Tim